2006-08-07

In defence of 404

Following the announce on the Semantic Web list of the publication of RDF geographical codes by french INSEE, a lively debate with Dan Connolly about access vs description.

2006-07-26

More thoughts on that Blue Glass

John Black commented on my previous post, providing links to interesting pieces of thoughts. Anatomy of a Reference and Ambiguity and Identity are certainly in the line of what we try to entangle here.
Let's put those pieces together. John's blue glass, physically tagged with its URI is a clear example of the difference between access and naming as explained by Pat Hayes. What is accessed using this http URI is an image of the blue glass, but the URI is intended to name the glass itself. Tagging physically the blue glass with a URI sticker or a bar code is something very close to what Pat calls ostention, but it's not the silver bullet to kill ambiguity.
As John clearly points, when you stick a tag somewhere in the physical world, you still need interpretation to know which part of the world is tagged this way, since the world is not "naturally" divided, things and their limits are always the result of some mental operation of division. So a common interpretation of the tag needs a common understanding of the limits of things, and having a common understanding of classes of things, and which kind of tags you put on which class of things is really useful. This is something well known in geographical maps. On ill-designed maps, names are not printed properly, and it's often unclear what (town, river, mountain ...) is named. In well-designed maps, there are a lot of implicit or explicit disambiguation tricks, such as fonts, colors, position of the name vs the named feature etc. One has to know all that to make sense of the map (actually many people are not able to make sense of a map properly). When you come to the ground, you have similar physical tags indicating towns, rivers, streets and house numbers, and you also need similar knowledge to construe those tags in context : this kind of sticker is for a town, that kind is for a street, and so on. And even so, what is the limit of a town, a street, a valley or a mountain remains basically undecidable.

[2016-06-20] John Black's Kashori archives have moved. The reference articles are now here:
http://www.kashori.com/archives/2006_06_11_archive.html
http://www.kashori.com/archives/2006_07_02_archive.html

2006-07-25

Ambiguity, Ostention and Description

Pat Hayes' In Defence of Ambiguity, presented at IRW 2006, has been on my desktop for weeks, and I take it as the most challenging food for thought currently available about the Semantic Web. If you have not yet read it, you should now.
There is only one point on which I would argue. Pat holds that reference can be made by ostention (gesticulation showing what you are about) or description. All Pat writes thereafter about description being inherently ambiguous, I strongly agree with : disambiguation being a contextual process, the more precise the description, the more ambiguity you get, and so on.
But I would hold that ostention is as ambiguous as description, so that reference is ambiguous in nature whatever the way it's done.
Suppose I am holding a book and ask you : "Have you read this?". The reference to "this" is by ostention, since I seem to hold and show "this". But the "ostentatum" indicated by "this" is actually some copy of some edition of some book. Does "this" refer to this specific copy, which happens to be my own personal copy (maybe annotated in some way), or is the referent the particular edition of which this specific copy is a sample, or is it the abstract entity, the book independent of any physical support, of which what I am currently holding happens to be some physical avatar? Every one of those interpretations is meaningful, and only the context of the conversation might disambiguate. So even with ostention, there is ambiguity left.

2006-06-20

Wikipedia's semantic cow paths

I've been quite silent here on this blog for two months, and meanwhile resumed a bit of my Wikipedian activity lately. Although I'd been an enthusiastic early adopter of Wikipedia back in 2001, I have a poor and episodic editing history so far. But every time I've been coming back to the editor dashboard after months or years of inactivity, I've been amazed by the tremendous qualitative growth of the toolkit made available to users. Wikipedia's growth has been stressed again and again in terms of quantity and quality of articles, languages, editors, popularity as a reference resource etc. But was has not been stressed enough is the parallel growth in terms of features supporting better search and editing. And many of those features are in fact adding a quality of information which makes it ready for semantic parsing, and easy RDF re-writing. The basis of it all is a sound use of URIs, names and namespace.
For example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcano defines without ambiguity the unique page dedicated to this geological feature, while http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcano_(disambiguation) is a hub to potential homonyms such as http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcano_(film). Links are provided to similar resources in other languages such as http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volcan. One can reasonably use any of those URIs to identify the concept "Volcano". But what about a class Volcano? Here come Wikipedia categories. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Active_volcanoes is ready-made for a class, and parsing the page will give you easily the list of instances, with a link to the full description page. This description itself is formatted using templates such as "infoboxes", so that a page in a category "Active Volcanoes" will yield standard properties in a standard format. Easy to turn this into a data base, and if one interprets the infobox elements as so many properties, turn it into a RDF description, and the infobox structure itself in a RDFS or OWL description of the matching class.
What should we learn from that? That from a collaborative and mostly non-directed process, are emerging cow paths which look more and more like semantic markup, ready to be spidered by smart parsers and tools, either to improve Wikipedia content itself (there are already a bunch of bots and agents doing that), or to extract of this amazing knowledge base any kind of structured data in whatever format, including implicit ontology, like structure of categories, attributes used, and the like. And my hunch is that this process will be quickly much more effective for Semantic Web building than many costly academic ontologies nobody will ever use.

[2010-04-08] : What is described here is exactly what DBpedia started in 2007

2006-04-11

More use cases for nondescript resources

nondescript is a funny word. Quite sure I did not catch its correct meaning when I first heard it. It has no real equivalent in French. Indescriptible is too strong, it refers to something too extraordinary to be described, whereas nondescript is actually too ordinary to deserve a proper description. Or is it that any description would miss the point? The free online dictionary says : Lacking distinctive qualities; having no individual character or form. Maybe in fact nondescripts remain such because those features which makes their individuality are too subtle to be captured, or this capture would be useless.
Anyway, let's take them as they are : no description. What does a nondescript look like in RDF? Well, easy, it's a resource with no description. No type, no identity, no properties, certainly not even worth a URI. A blank node with no property whatsoever. Rings a bell now? After the previous post, I've come out with more use cases for those nondescript resources, and how natural language uses them as binding points. Examples

John walks through the neighborhood where Ann is working.

:John :walksThrough _:n
:Ann :worksIn _:n

In The Rule of Four (currently reading) Vincent and Richard have different theses about Hypnerotomachia Poliphili. Paul prefers Richard's thesis.

:Vincent :hasThesis _:tV
:Richard :hasThesis _:tR
:Paul :prefers _:tR

Now the "Class or Concept" example comes naturally as just another case

a:Restaurant a owl:Class
b:Restaurant a skos:Concept

a:Restaurant :represents _:x
b:Restaurant :represents _:x

Cloud hidden, whereabouts unknown. (Similar stuff in the early '70s)

2006-04-04

Identifying things - blank nodes again

Still trying to figure if the hubject seeds are likely to grow somewhere, so I dropped one today on Danny Ayers' blog, as a comment on a post itself commenting on another one from Jon Udell where is introduced the cool notion of collaborative aliasing. "What a concept!" will say Jack. And actually, it's no more no less the idea that hubjects can be created out of aggregation of resources being "about the same thing". An aliasing service, which really looks like tagging.
So my suggestion again is here to use blank tagging, that is, allow users, in a simple way, to make all those resources point to the same blank node.
Now something is slowly coming from the back of my mind. I thought for a while we needed a specific and mysterious vocabulary to do that, hubjects and the like. Since this kind of stuff is far from being on the track of adoption, maybe using more popular and less exotic vocabulary, such as dc:subject or something similar would make the whole thing more understandable. Seems there is no formal opposition to declare things like:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00006RCLH dc:subject _:b
http://labs.oclc.org/xisbn/068981836X dc:subject _:b
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Call_of_the_Wild dc:subject _:b

And actually, any other property could be used as well, such as the following, to take the example from Jon Udell's post
http://upcoming.org/venue/3669/ a:venue _:x
http://eventful.com/venues/V0-001-000150985-3 a:venue _:x

This kind of declaration keeps completely agnostic on what a venue in general, and this particular one actually is. It simply says that the two resources are about the same one.

2006-03-15

Identity vs Meaning

Under this really boring title "The Semantics Are Important", Seth Ladd in his Semergence blog is making a really good point :
The identity is singular. The meaning is relative.
In other words, identity and identifiers can be shared, global, universal, whereas semantics/meaning, such as expressed in a particular RDF graph, is local, relative, context-bound, perspective-defined. And therefore multiple, orthogonal, non-compatible, globally inconsistent.
I like it more and more. This goes along the same lines as Pat Hayes' recent post, and puts again the question of how to deal with context. I'm not sure now, munching over Pat's arguments, that the context always needs to be explicited. I've been working those days on SKOS used to express simplified view of hierarchies (of any kind) in an OWL ontology. In some OWL ontology, one would find
a:SomeRegion a:partOf a:SomeCountry
In a simplified SKOS view
a:SomeRegion skos:broader a:Some Country
Reasoners and RDF stores are happy with the OWL version, search engines, taxonomy managers and the like are happy with the SKOS version. So one perspective by kind of tools/applications. What would not make sense would be to merge them, and entail that a:SomeRegion is at the same time an instance of a:Region and skos:Concept. It is not at the same time, it is one in some application context, and the other one in another context. No problem with that. So what is a:SomeRegion in essence, to use this arrogant word I saw passing in the previous post? Well, it's neti, neti, neither this, nor that. No big deal. Who cares?
Set this question about a week ago on the SKOS forum. An astounding silence has been the answer so far ...
[2013-08-01] : Still waiting for an answer ... more than 7 years after the issue is still open.